| Forum » General » Buying top goal scorers | Date | |
|---|---|---|
|
1647 msgs.
International
|
Only his current team can avoid that nothing for the devs to do,his current team need to high his clause to avoid been paid @Horath said: this has been around since the game was release, people have been doing it for well over 2 years, was never punishable, so nothing (legaly) wrong about it.. though i agree, it's really bad that this exists. |
15/06/2013 22:47 |
| - Div/Gr | ||
|
Username
203 msgs.
Substitute
|
I totally agree with Kingofthehill, this thing should be stopped as soon as possible. @Horath said: this has been around since the game was release, people have been doing it for well over 2 years, was never punishable, so nothing (legaly) wrong about it.. though i agree, it's really bad that this exists. @Horat, i don't understand why, if something has been done for over 2 years, it could not become punishable. Laws are made by men, and can be changed during the time: considering a lot of honest managers are complaining about this, it could be the time to prevent this unfair beahviour. How? Punishing with economic sanctions, as for fraudulent trades. Or, more simply, clearing players' statistics when they change team, so noone will have interest in buying top scorers of 3 divisions below anymore. In your opinion, it could be done? |
18/06/2013 02:20 |
| - Div/Gr | ||
|
1647 msgs.
International
|
Ooch! That too much sanction,well not assigned. To buy a top player be the best option for manager who need gb,but to manager who know the benefit of his/er player in top scorer menu will high the player clause the can scared some managers,because it common in div5 team to div6 elmilo said: I totally agree with Kingofthehill, this thing should be stopped as soon as possible. @Horath said: this has been around since the game was release, people have been doing it for well over 2 years, was never punishable, so nothing (legaly) wrong about it.. though i agree, it's really bad that this exists. @Horat, i don't understand why, if something has been done for over 2 years, it could not become punishable. Laws are made by men, and can be changed during the time: considering a lot of honest managers are complaining about this, it could be the time to prevent this unfair beahviour. How? Punishing with economic sanctions, as for fraudulent trades. Or, more simply, clearing players' statistics when they change team, so noone will have interest in buying top scorers of 3 divisions below anymore. In your opinion, it could be done? |
18/06/2013 08:06 |
| - Div/Gr | ||
|
11 msgs.
Cadet
|
It's an annoying thing this one but that's unfortunately how life goes. I've just lost my top scorer to a D3 team purely for GB's, I'm not complaining too much as I made a pretty profit on him anyway. Other than having a transfer window (not practical) there would need to be a rule change to stop what really is cheating. | 18/06/2013 14:48 |
| - Div/Gr | ||
|
Username
203 msgs.
Substitute
|
No, it's not how life goes, even real life or other managerial games... In general, if a certain behaviour that has been always considered acceptable, from a certain moment is considered wrong, rules can be changed to forbid it. Statistics's reset is a so obvious thing when a player is bought by a team of a different league, that i wonder it's not considered here. Yes, probably a fine is "legally" difficult, but stats reset is the way it goes all around the world. When a player is bought by a certain team (i.e. player X is bought by a "serie A" team, from a "serie B" team), all the goals the player scored in the lower division (serie B) are not counted for the "serie A top scorer table" (old stats are kept only if the trade is made by two teams of the SAME league). It's obvious, and i don't understand what is the problem/difficulty in erase old statistics after a trade. Cheers | 18/06/2013 15:09 |
| - Div/Gr | ||
|
830 msgs.
MVP of the game
|
Why everyone say it is cheat? If it is part of the game than it isn't cheat. I mean I don't do that, but look at this situation from .pt server. A guy registered two weeks ago, until then my player was top scorer. This guy buys 3 players and his IM becomes top scorer. So shouldn't I also buy someone to beat him? He doesn't even know about it and I believe I deserve it more. Here I don't deserve top scorer award so I won't do it. But why would I be a cheat for doing that on .pt server? Now this kind of situation is possible to happen here, someone buys a player and unintentionally player becomes top scorer. If the league is active what do you think it will happen? That been said, if it is part of the game no one is to blame but those who haven't put higher release clauses on their scorers or game developers. Not people buying players. Well, that's just my opinion. |
18/06/2013 15:15 |
| - Div/Gr | ||
|
1647 msgs.
International
|
I support that,in life all stat goes off when a Spanish top player were sell to English league,if this could be done it better but the game not classify all team fight for thesame div1 elmilo said: No, it's not how life goes, even real life or other managerial games... In general, if a certain behaviour that has been always considered acceptable, from a certain moment is considered wrong, rules can be changed to forbid it. Statistics's reset is a so obvious thing when a player is bought by a team of a different league, that i wonder it's not considered here. Yes, probably a fine is "legally" difficult, but stats reset is the way it goes all around the world. When a player is bought by a certain team (i.e. player X is bought by a "serie A" team, from a "serie B" team), all the goals the player scored in the lower division (serie B) are not counted for the "serie A top scorer table" (old stats are kept only if the trade is made by two teams of the SAME league). It's obvious, and i don't understand what is the problem/difficulty in erase old statistics after a trade. Cheers |
18/06/2013 15:45 |
| - Div/Gr | ||
|
Username
1368 msgs.
International
|
Miroslav"Ćiro"Blažević said: Why everyone say it is cheat? If it is part of the game than it isn't cheat. I mean I don't do that, but look at this situation from .pt server. A guy registered two weeks ago, until then my player was top scorer. This guy buys 3 players and his IM becomes top scorer. So shouldn't I also buy someone to beat him? He doesn't even know about it and I believe I deserve it more. Here I don't deserve top scorer award so I won't do it. But why would I be a cheat for doing that on .pt server? Now this kind of situation is possible to happen here, someone buys a player and unintentionally player becomes top scorer. If the league is active what do you think it will happen? That been said, if it is part of the game no one is to blame but those who haven't put higher release clauses on their scorers or game developers. Not people buying players. Well, that's just my opinion. However if he hadn't done it in the first place due to restrictions then this wouldn't be an issue. I don't think you would be wrong here to buy another player to be first in the scorers table as that's what should have happened. Milo's example of a player moving from Serie B to Serie A or something along those lines perfectly illustrates the point that statistics should just be reset to avoid any problems. |
18/06/2013 15:47 |
| - Div/Gr | ||
|
1382 msgs.
International
|
I say.. Start a petition in suggestion area for statistic reset or dig up an old thread about issue. Edited by cmccourt 18-06-2013 16:01 |
18/06/2013 16:00 |
| - Div/Gr | ||
|
Username
1798 msgs.
International
|
you do realize that if @'s wanted to punish anyone doing this, it would take, like, A LOT of effort for little reward? There's hundreds of leagues, thousands upon thousands of teams and thousands upon thousands of transfers. We would have to check just about ever striker transfer in game and then figure whether he was a top scorer when he was purchased, whether that caused the new owner to win the GBs, whether the trade was within limits, whether he really just bought him to get top scorer or because he wanted the player? No, it's no possible. The only way is for developers to make a change, otherwise it's simply not possible. And 2 years ago they said they don't plan to make the change (at that time, it was near future i think, doubt anything changed by now tho). These kind of threads pop up at the end of every season, so you're not trying to dig up the hot water i'm afraid.  |
18/06/2013 16:33 |
| - Div/Gr | ||
2
